The federal prosecutor disqualification involving Sigal Chattah was not a ruling that she committed a crime or that every indictment issued during her tenure was invalid. It was a decision about who may legally lead a U.S. Attorney’s Office when a presidentially appointed, Senate-confirmed position becomes vacant. On August 17, 2026, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit held that the Justice Department could not extend Chattah’s control of federal prosecutions in Nevada by appointing her first assistant after the vacancy already existed or by delegating all of the U.S. attorney’s powers to her. The decision preserved a lower court order disqualifying her from supervising certain criminal cases. At the same time, the appellate court did not dismiss the underlying indictments, leaving the appointment issue separate from the defendants’ criminal liability.

How Sigal Chattah became Nevada’s interim prosecutor
The sequence began when U.S. Attorney Jason Frierson resigned on January 17, 2025. Under the Federal Vacancies Reform Act, then-First Assistant U.S. Attorney Sue Fahami initially became the acting head of the office. The attorney general later used a different statute, 28 U.S.C. Section 546, to appoint Chattah as interim U.S. attorney effective April 1, 2025. The Justice Department announced that she would supervise federal criminal prosecutions and civil matters in Nevada, which has federal offices in Las Vegas and Reno.
That interim appointment carried a 120-day limit. With the term approaching its end, Chattah resigned as interim U.S. attorney on July 28, 2025. The attorney general named her first assistant that same day and argued the designation would allow her to act as U.S. attorney once again under the vacancies law. The department also designated her a special attorney under separate federal statutes and purported to give her extensive prosecutorial powers.
Why criminal defendants challenged her authority
Several people indicted in Nevada federal courts after the attempted transition challenged Chattah’s authority. The indictments had been signed by assistant U.S. attorneys rather than by Chattah personally, but her name appeared on documents identifying her as acting U.S. attorney. Defense counsel argued that the succession arrangement sidestepped the legal process for filling the top federal prosecutor’s position and sought dismissal of their indictments or her disqualification.
A district court disqualified Chattah from participation in or supervision of the challenged prosecutions. However, it declined to erase the indictments merely because the office leadership arrangement was defective. The government appealed the disqualification, and the defendants sought review of the refusal to dismiss their cases. The resulting appellate opinion addressed both tracks but resolved them differently.
What the Ninth Circuit ruled on August 17, 2026
The Ninth Circuit affirmed the disqualification. It explained that the Federal Vacancies Reform Act’s automatic succession rule normally applies to someone who was already first assistant when the relevant vacancy arose. Chattah was placed in that role months after Frierson resigned. The court rejected the idea that an official could acquire acting status retroactively by being assigned the first-assistant title to an office that was already vacant.
The court also rejected the Justice Department’s alternative theory that general delegation powers could accomplish what the vacancies statute did not permit. If a department could delegate every power of a Senate-confirmed office to one unconfirmed person, it could effectively bypass the vacancy rules. The appellate judges concluded that this was inconsistent with the law’s structure.
The defendants’ appeals from the orders denying dismissal of their indictments were dismissed for lack of appellate jurisdiction at that stage. Thus, the decision should not be characterized as an appellate ruling that all Nevada prosecutions involving Chattah must be thrown out. It resolved her authority to supervise those matters, not the merits of the charges against the defendants.
The larger dispute over temporary federal appointments
Most U.S. attorneys are appointed by the president and confirmed by the Senate, while Congress has provided limited mechanisms for temporary service when an office becomes vacant. The controversy arose because the administration sought to retain an interim appointee beyond the statutory period. Comparable disputes emerged in other federal districts, although each depends on its own appointments and procedural history.
President Donald Trump nominated attorney George Kelesis for the Nevada post in February 2026. The nomination process was separate from the litigation involving Chattah. An appointment dispute of this kind can affect supervision, filings and possible remedies in particular cases, but it is not evidence that a prosecutor engaged in personal corruption. The central holding was narrower and more concrete: an after-the-fact first-assistant designation and wholesale delegation cannot substitute for lawful appointment to the vacant U.S. attorney position.